Tag Archives: state immunity patent infringement

Solicitor General’s patent infringement suit against California.

Solicitor General patent infringement suit against an aggressive State of California hiding behind 11th Amendment.

I was reading this morning’s post on the Patently-O Patent Law Blog about the Biomedical Patent Management Corp. (BPMC) v. California Department of Health Services (on petition for certiorari) brief by the Solicitor General.

In short, I feel that the Court is spending too much time looking for the perfect case to justify the ruling (a.k.a. law) they are looking to implement. However, I believe that injustice is being done because bad law is being formed on the lower courts because the Court is not hearing these poorly-decided cases. I feel this is bad practice, and I implore the courts to stop this practice. Their job at their level is not to “legislate from the bench,” but to resolve issues where the lower courts have made errors. My comments to the Patently-O article is below:

TJ, I think the problem is that the SG is looking to pick and choose the best cases to create the law they’re looking to implement. Metabolite v. Labcorp was a good candidate to take on the “thinking step” patentability issue, but nothing significant happened, thus no material change to the patent law system. Now, we have a case where the Cali gov’t is enforcing their patents, but hiding under 11th Amendment immunities. Again, the SG claimed this was not the right case to create this kind of law, noting that the issue is really a problem. I can think of a few more examples of this off the top of my head.

Pardon the baseball analogy, but it’s unfortunate that the courts are looking for a slow pitch down the middle to assert the law they wish to implement. Perfect cases only come once in a while, and we are racking up issues that need to be addressed, and the courts keep going silent. This is not justice — not for the litigants, not for the patent law system, and not for the country. Stop looking for the perfect cases, and make the wronged litigants whole by hearing cases where there has been an injustice done at the lower courts, because by being SILENT, you are creating precedent and BAD LAW. Just stop it.

The Court needs to put a stop to looking for the “perfect” cases so that they can “legislate from the bench” and must return to adjudicating cases to right a wrong when the lower courts have gone awry.


If you are interested in a patent litigation attorney or a patent attorney in Houston, TX, I have started an informative website using the name Patent Prophet which will be a resource for those who wish to obtain a patent or for those who would like to find out how to prevent companies from stealing their inventions. Services include help with entering into IP Agreements & Licensing options, IP Enforcement and Litigation, Strategic Counseling, and much more.